Igniting your Natural Genius - Section 3: Unlearning by Prasad Kaipa and Steve Johnson Section 1 | Section 2 | Section 3 | Section 4 | Section 5 | Section 6 This chapter forms the third section of a manuscript (work in progress) titled Igniting Your Natural Genius. This manuscript elaborates the learning framework developed the Mithya Institute. You can see the model or read about it by selecting Bicycle Built for Two or Learning Coaching and Inspiration.
Introduction to the unlearning chapter
When we join a new company, we learn to do things the way others do
and when we move to new town, we pay attention to local people and
unconsciously pick up their ways of saying, doing and being. We get conditioned by the environment we live in and it is mostly automatic and even necessary for our survival. Conditioning is inevitable, sometimes even desirable. We will always have our own perspectives of the world, even if my perspective does not have much to do with your perspective. Most conflicts come from
such differences. But just as we cannot plant new crops without first uprooting
the old ones and giving the new seeds a chance, we need to unlearn before
we can learn anew. There are countless books on the subject of learning and
teaching, yet unlearning is not given a mention even though it might be the
most important stage of human development. How do we unlearn our patterns
and develop new patterns? How do we escape the box?
As every teacher knows, if someone has no intention of learning it is very difficult to teach them anything at all. Intentionality is the key ingredient that allows creative tension to build and the unlearning process to be effective. In this section, we will first address intention and then uncover the process of unlearning...
Exit doors in mental prisons are invisible; until we look for them
If we have no intention of escaping from the box we will never even notice opportunities to do so.
Divine Parvathi asked her husband Lord Shiva about the beggar. She asked him to give the poor man riches. Lord Shiva told her that until the beggar asked for prosperity, he could not give it to him. The beggar has to experience a desire to go beyond his poverty and then, Shiva said, he could help.
Goddess Parvathi was not satisfied. She wanted to try anyway, so with Lord Shiva's encouragement, Parvathi dropped a bag of gold coins in the path of the beggar just before he started walking down his usual street.
As it happened, however, as he woke up that morning, the beggar had a desire to learn what blind people experience on the streets of Calcutta. He decided that the only way was to close his eyes and go about his daily routine, and hence he walked past his fortune.
This classic story is not, of course, too realistic, and it is possible that
the beggar would have chosen some other day to experiment with the experience
of blindness if he had been told about the gold. Or he may not -- we will
never know. But it does serve to highlight the topic of intention. Unless
we actively look for something, we tend not to see it.
This is true both literally and metaphorically. Our conscious mind would
be inundated with excess data if we studied everything within view with maximum
intensity. That is the great benefit of our ability to see patterns; once
glanced at and recognized, it can safely be ignored enabling us to concentrate
on newer information. But sometimes, as with optical illusions, try as we
might we cannot avoid our minds coming to conclusions that are quite wrong.
The same is true of our thinking process. In the box that we have chosen to live in, we need to make the effort to look for the way out; it will not be apparent otherwise. The door has become too commonplace to notice, and after a while we might even forget the need for a door in the first place.
While I grew up in India, I did not care very much about Indian values, its heritage or its culture since I was mostly unconscious of what it means to be an Indian. When I moved to the United States, my culture, values and beliefs came into sharper focus and the contrast provided an opportunity to learn more about my previous conditioning. If I had never left India, I probably would have never wanted to learn many of the things I've now learned about myself.
--Thomas Carlyle, Count Cagliostro, 1833
To go vaguely in the
right direction is to go in the wrong direction.
There is no such thing as a vague intention to look for change. If any intention
is vague, it cannot be an intention. If it is vague, it cannot be an intention.
Every large bookstore has self-help book shelves full of exciting exaltations
like `do it now!' , 'take charge!' and 'turn your goals into a winning formula
for success!' They mostly say that if you don't know where you're headed,
how do you expect to get there?
They are right, of course. In this book we have tried to avoid the breathless
prose of the instant enrichment genre, but there is no doubt that intentions
to change are a necessary ingredient of the process. It is easy to fool even
ourselves by going through the motions of planning something when we have
no real intention of carrying it out. We might, for example, buy a language
tape that remains on our shelf, unused. Who would do such a thing? The publishing
industry will tell you that it is a common phenomenon. We may do it out of
vanity, or we may be tricking ourselves. We may like the concept of learning
or growing, but today is not a good time to start.
We could even play the language tape and still not learn from it, because
without any genuine intention to learn it will flow over our heads. Grim
repetition will fail. We need to want to learn so much that the process itself
will be enjoyable. We can therefore dramatically increase our rate of learning
if we remind ourselves that we really do want to, perhaps by visualizing
not only the benefits afterwards but the pleasure during the process. Or,
rather than be inhibited by the language tape and considering the course
a chore, we would do better to simply play it one day and see if it is
interesting, with no heavy agenda attached and, consequently, no possibility
of failure either.
When we travel by plane, how many of us pay attention to the instructions
the flight attendants give on the right ways to buckle up, and where to find
oxygen masks and flotation devices? The ritual bores us. However, if the
plane developed serious engine trouble in mid flight, everyone would suddenly
pay very close attention indeed. Although such motivation could hardly be
higher in survival terms, because of the stress of the situation some people
would still miss many of the instructions given. Because there is no inherent
pleasure in learning about the equipment itself, the mind still finds itself
wandering.
We only relate to information when it matches the level we perceive we are
at. Maslow suggested that human needs change and grow. We begin with basic
survival needs, and only when they are satisfied do we progress to stimulation
needs (activity, exploration), then safety and security, followed by love
and belonging, self esteem, and, finally, self actualization.
We can quickly revert to lower levels, for example in an emergency or illness.
We would trade our home and all our wealth for a life raft or a cure for
a life-threatening sickness. Our ability to learn, being a direct function
of our interest in the subject under review, generally parallels these changing
levels, although during moments of transformation we can leapfrog entire
levels in a moment.
-- Edna St.Vincent Millay, Untitled poem, Make Bright the arrows, 1940
We cannot plant new crops before we uproot the old. We need to unlearn before we can learn/A>
The master offered tea to the professor and he accepted. While pouring tea, the master did not stop when the cup was full, but continued to pour until the professor stopped him. The bewildered professor was told that the cup resembled his brain and unless he was willing to empty it, nothing more would fit inside!
At first, this concept seems contrary to the idea of the unlimited mind.
However, although the brain does indeed seem limitless in its acquisition
of facts, a new idea which fundamentally conflicts with an old one cannot
enter our mental box until the old one is discarded.
There is a book called Maiden Voyage in which Tania Aebi, an eighteen-year-old
dropout going nowhere, was offered a challenge by her father. He bought a
boat and challenged her to go sailing in it for two years on her own and
support herself during that time. If she earned enough money during those
two years to support herself, she could keep the boat.
Tania was so excited about getting away from her parents and having fun that
she didn't view as a chore the many lessons she had to take on navigation
and survival techniques. Her negative ways began to change. Once she began
her voyage her survival was dependent on how well she could navigate. Very
quickly she picked up what she needed to learn, and she spent the next two
and half years and 27,000 miles sailing around the world, discovering herself.
Until the challenge, Tania was locked in a rigid mental box with a pessimistic
and non-participatory outlook and an uncertain future. The challenge helped
her to unlearn her old thinking and develop an entirely new context for learning.
I had an airplane pilot in my workshop who was learning to fly a glider.
He told me as a pilot it was much more difficult for him to learn to fly
a glider, than for his wife to learn, who was not a pilot. He kept looking
for controls that were not there. He spent much of his early lessons trying
to relate and compare the two types of aircraft. Meanwhile, the complete
novices made progress from day one. What we already know gets in the way
of what we want to learn.
When we unlearn, we generate anew rather than reformulate the same old stuff.
Creativity and innovation bubble up during the process of unlearning. This
is not mere modification or restructuring of old material; once we remove
our blinders, the world becomes quite different, with new possibilities and
innovative approaches to situations that previously seemed stale or difficult.
If we wish to blossom, we should remember that a seed will only germinate
if it ceases to be a seed.
-- Alfred, Lord Tennyson; `The Ancient Sage' 1885
We might travel the world for a lifetime; trapped inside our own jail
The only barriers to learning are those we have created. Many people assume
that once someone is settled in to their box they cannot fundamentally change
their patterns, beliefs, and personalities. People are generally resigned
to our `inadequacies' and assume that this is the way they always will be.
Such thinking becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy because they think they
see validation for their beliefs everywhere they look.
When in this position they are so used to the box that it becomes invisible
to them, (but perhaps not to others). Learning is not possible until we unlearn
about our current box.
There is an old fable about a frog in a pond. A new frog arrived from the
ocean. He asked this visitor how big was the ocean. `The ocean is very large
and the pond is so small compared to the ocean', the second frog responded.
The frog in the pond could not imagine anything bigger than the pond it lived
in and therefore it went away thinking that the second frog was the biggest
liar it had ever met.
-- Francis Bacon, The Advancement of Learning, 1605
Self esteem and self confidence are very much part of the box in which we
imprison ourselves. Once boxed in, it is difficult, but again not impossible,
to break out. But only we hold the key.
While I was leading a workshop in India, a woman told me that she attempted
to learn to drive twice and then gave up. Why? The car stalled three or four
times while she was attempting to change gears. She had not mastered the
interplay between clutch, accelerator and the brake pedal. She did not have
the tolerance for her 'mistakes' and decided that she was not good enough
to learn how to drive a car.
I also remember meeting a brilliant young doctor who had a mental blind-spot.
For some reason she was absolutely petrified of taking answering machine
messages for other people. If ever she attempted it, her mind would freeze
and she either would not listen or she would write down incomplete messages.
This was despite the fact that she knew some messages could be urgent. Instead
of seeking help, she was adamant that she could never master this, and she
remained totally unwilling to be coached.
Steve: The same applies to the world of computers. Some people are so frightened
of having to use them that the term `computer phobic' is in common use. I
used to work for a computer hardware manufacturer who ran teams of customer
training consultants. Sometimes the entire installation of an expensive computer
system, perhaps replacing one that was archaic and error-prone system, would
hinge on one person who refused to have anything to do with it because of
a lack of self confidence.
It was frequently a delicate psychological situation; the trainer would need
skills far beyond those learned in computer school to prevent emotional factors
overwhelming the customer's office. Until a breakthrough occurred, the person
being trained would sometimes become physically ill with worry and stress.
After the breakthrough, a sudden transformation would take place; that same
person could often be seen enthusiastically showing off the system with pride,
and recommending it to acquaintances.
The solution to these blockages is usually not found in merely spending more
time practicing, because no amount of repetition automatically improves low
self confidence. Our expectations get in the way of our learning; only when
the attitude changed was there a breakthrough.
My son Pravin has been learning to swim with air-wings that support his weight.
One day we both were getting ready to swim and I was cleaning the pool. When
I turned my back to him, Pravin jumped into the pool and in his excitement,
forgot to wear his wings. He was able to swim for about a minute before noticing
the absence of his wings and the extra effort that he had to exert to stay
afloat. Then fear took over and he frantically shouted to get my attention
and stopped swimming. Luckily, I rescued him right away and even attempted
to get him back in the water so that his fear would not create a box around
his mind.
Steve Johnson adds:
Sometimes we meet someone who we recognize as `driven'. When they say they
are going to do something we know it will happen because they, themselves,
are so sure. It is simply going to happen, no matter what.
These cases display more than desire or motivation. Something larger than
that seems to be at work. It is the strength of that conviction that gives
it its force, and this applies to learning as much as anything. They have
learned to make things happen by believing they will.
I once heard the story of a young boy in a small village who spent years
in the same grade and was given up as mute and retarded.
A new teacher joined the school, and taking note of the child, spent a long
time studying him. Committed to helping him, he attempted many ways to engage
him. One day he drew a figure on the blackboard. It was a drawing of the
boy's dog.
The boy was visibly moved by the image, and asked the teacher whether it
was his dog that was being drawn. Encouraged by the boy's response, the teacher
spent the next few minutes finding more information about the dog. Then he
wrote 'RAMA,' the name of the dog, below the drawing. The student was puzzled
and asked what it was. The teacher told him that it is the dog's name and
asked the boy to write the name down. The boy burst into tears and confessed
that he did not know how to read or write. It was clear that he was so ashamed
of his lack of progress at school that he had given up long ago. He needed
to unlearn his opinion of his capabilities.
The teacher gently guided the child in writing the name Rama, and once he
wrote it there was a visible transformation in the boy. The boy went on to
advance through the school effortlessly in the next few years and went on
to become a scholar in his own right.
-- Sir Thomas Browne Religion Medici, 1642
Compliments create the
very skills they are complimenting
We can change someone's self image and beliefs by the way we acknowledge
them.
Angeles Arrien, a cross cultural anthropologist, once said that each person
is a leader, and effective leaders are ones who know how to acknowledge others.
She also says that there are four ways to acknowledge a person:
The power of such positive comments is such that it can cause a change to
occur in the other person; once their beliefs and their self perceptions
are changed, anything can happen. Because of this, they start to focus and
develop in that area. It becomes self fulfilling.
-- Mark Twain Notebook, 1935
The person with the highest IQ may be the least intelligent
Learning begins with an appreciation of our differences and realities.
Everyone has heard of IQ tests, and many assume that they are the best way
of assessing intelligence. It now emerges that this is a very narrow test
indeed, so its persistence is highly misleading. We need to unlearn about
IQ importance.
Howard Gardner writes of multiple intelligences, arguing that we have at
least seven different ways of knowing the world. Instead of merely the
logico-mathematical intelligence that is measured in standard IQ tests, Gardner
talks about other, equally valid intelligences. They are language, spatial
representation, musical thinking, kinesthetic intelligence, interpersonal
and intra-personal intelligences. In a world obsessed with the standard IQ
model, we run the risk of demotivating intelligent people who fail a limited
and fairly arbitrary but ubiquitous test. Furthermore, those who pass may
be given undue accolades, and be closed to further learning.
We all use our very different ways of relating to the world when solving
the problems that we have; in other words, we all have different approaches
to solving problems. It is also now widely recognized that we have different
learning styles , learning modalities (visual, auditory and kinesthetic)
and creativity styles.
Unless we use different approaches when engaging different people, we may
not hardly be heard, let alone hope to communicate in any meaningful way.
Everyone has strengths in one or more of these seven areas, which combine
to become part of that person's individual reality. If we find that we cannot
easily understand or like someone, by speaking to another of their `selves'
we can find talents and gifts we little suspected. This is true empathy;
consciously learning about their world and dealing in their reality.
-- George Santayana Little Essays, 192
It is not our good health that makes us happy, but our happiness that gives us good health
If one of our most important realities is our health, we have more ability
to influence it than we used to think. We need to look at the complete picture
when wishing to accelerate learning; our bodies and our minds are not separable.
I met a high level administrative officer in India. He told me the story
of his son, who was diagnosed as being severely mentally retarded. Almost
everyone gave up on the child when doctors told the family that he would
probably never be capable of eating his own food let alone taking care of
himself. That is, everybody gave up except the mother, who spent all her
time taking care of him, singing to him, telling him stories, taking him
for walks. This continued for years.
This same son is now in his second year of music college, can type 100 words
a minute, speak three languages, and can cook, clean and take care of himself.
Doctors and educators come from all over to see this miracle and the only
answer the mother has for them is that there is nothing that cannot be cured
by love. She never, for one second, believed that her son was a vegetable
and she did not let the child believe it either. Whatever mechanism took
part in this case, it begs the question how many times have we ourselves
have given up on learning new tasks just because we felt incapable? How many
chances do we give children to learn before we brand them uneducable?
It seems, therefore, that we can learn how to improve our own health. There
is much evidence of the relationship between our mental state and our body's
immunity to disease, as well as our ability to learn. During depression we
not only find it hard to learn but we increase our forgetfulness. If we are
surrounded by an environment where we experience trust, love and compassion,
healing between inner and outer selves starts. Learning can only thrive when
we feel free to learn, which in turn only takes place when we feel whole,
which is our natural state.
-- E. M. Forster, Two Cheers for Democracy, 1951
In this chapter on unlearning, we investigated the process of innovative or generative learning through the process of unlearning. This seems like a contradiction, however, we need to throw away the old models and replace them with better ones before significant new learning can take place.
We need to intend to change, because the process is not automatic. We best experience a desire to learn in a whole or loving environment. As we become aware of what lies outside the box, we see and hear things we were previously oblivious of. We gradually develop a creative tension between our desire to change and our resistance, which is a fear of the unknown; we confront the old model, unlearn what was holding us back, and begin to open up enough to dissolve the old box, and create anew. That moment is one of breakthrough and great awareness. For a while there is reduced attachment to the past
and reduced anxiety about the future.
Such transformations lead to dramatic increases in openness and create a space, a gap between current reality and the future vision. Learning in such a gap is the subject of the another chapter. If you like to read the chapter on Openness chapter, Click on Openness: Exploring the Gap
You can see the learning framework which includes unlearning as an integral part, you may click here: The Learning Framework
Other Chapters of 'Igniting Your Natural Genius'
You can send any comments or suggestions by clicking here: comments@mithya.com
Copyright 1998, 1999, The Mithya Institute for Learning. All rights reserved. |